Should "sort-of" cops be allowed to carry firearms off-duty?
Democratic candidate for McHenry County sheriff Mike Mahon issued a press release earlier this week, questioning Sheriff's Nygren's denial of toting privileges for 230 McHenry County Sheriff's Department corrections (jail) officers, court security officers and process servers.
When I was a reserve deputy sheriff in Colorado in the 1970s, a newly-elected sheriff changed our commission from full-time to on-duty only, although he let us keep our concealed carry cards. I recognized the financial liability immediately, and a number of other reserve deputies and I stopped carrying our firearms off-duty.
We warned one particular reserve deputy not to carry. He had about ten years' reserve experience, including in Dade County, Fla. He thought and acted like a cop, which was good, but we guessed he might forget the change in policy, if he found himself in harm's way. In fact, he did.
One night he found himself witnessing a crime, and he drew his weapon and announced "Police." That was a huge mistake. Although he had been, he wasn't. Just like we had told him he might instinctively do. And the sheriff hung him out to dry.
Another ticklish situation developed, because I owned my own police-equipped motorcycle, including two-way radio on the department's frequency. I lived about 15 miles from the department headquarters and, under the sheriff's new policy, I was not "on-duty" until I checked in at the department and picked up a portable radio.
I asked about this possible situation. Let's say I was riding to the department, in uniform and armed but off-duty, and a person notified me of a bank robbery while I was stopped at a red light. What should I do? Hand him a dime and tell him to phone it in?
Since I was technically off-duty, I was not going to go to the bank!
Back to the 2010 problem in McHenry County. Should these non-sworn MCSD employees be allowed to carry firearms off-duty?
Until I see studies that indicate a high degree of risk to them when they are off-duty, I'll say they should not be allowed to carry off-duty or to and from work. Without general powers of arrest, they are civilians when they leave work. If they see a crime in progress while they are off-duty, let them call it in, just like the rest of us have to.
And, when we all have the right to carry a firearm, they can certainly exercise that right, too.